As England prepare to host India in a much-anticipated five-Test series beginning at Headingley, attention turns to the pivotal duels that could swing the outcome. With high-profile names like Jasprit Bumrah and Ollie Pope in the spotlight, and emerging threats like Shoaib Bashir waiting in the wings, this series promises a cocktail of pressure, pedigree, and unpredictability. BBC Sport, with data insight from CricViz, breaks down where the contest will be won and lost.
Ollie Pope’s double-edged sword
For all the optimism surrounding England’s aggressive red-ball approach under Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum, few players personify its risks and rewards more than Ollie Pope. Retained as vice-captain and No.3 batter, Pope remains a high-ceiling, high-variance proposition—capable of brilliance, but also vulnerable to implosions.
Pope’s 2024 has been emblematic of his career trajectory. Among his three Test centuries this year was a masterful 196 in Hyderabad—a definitive performance against the very opponents he’ll now face again. But such innings are counterbalanced by a staggering inconsistency. In 27 other knocks this year, he failed to reach double figures 13 times, more than any other top-seven batter in that span.
Statistically, 34% of Pope’s 3,301 career Test runs have come from just six innings. When he settles, he dominates. But getting to that point remains a consistent challenge, exacerbated by a high false-shot percentage (18.4%)—the highest of any regular No.3 in Test cricket over the past six years. This lack of control at the crease could be England’s Achilles heel in the early overs, especially given the threat posed by one bowler in particular.
Jasprit Bumrah: more than a nemesis
That bowler is, of course, Jasprit Bumrah—the man who may define the series as much as anyone with bat or ball. For Pope, he is a personal tormentor. Only Ravichandran Ashwin has dismissed him more times in Tests. Bumrah has accounted for Pope five times, and it’s not hard to see why.
The Indian spearhead specialises in a length—7 to 8 metres from the stumps—that is particularly troublesome for Pope in English conditions. It’s an area Bumrah targets with clinical precision, often in tandem with Mohammed Siraj. Add to that Pope’s extraordinary susceptibility to being bowled by pace in England (39% of such dismissals), and the matchup becomes a strategic landmine for England. But Bumrah’s influence stretches far beyond his duels with Pope. At this stage of his career, he’s arguably the most impactful fast bowler in world cricket. Despite playing only 12 Tests at home, he has taken 145 of his 205 wickets in the ‘SENA’ countries—South Africa, England, New Zealand, and Australia—where conditions favour pace. It’s a record unmatched by any other Indian quick, and it underlines why England must do more than just “survive” him. They must outthink him.
The good news for England? Bumrah may not play all five matches. India’s management have hinted at rotating their premier paceman, potentially limiting his appearances to three or four. But even brief cameos could be series-defining if England don’t plan wisely.
How to neutralise Bumrah: pressure elsewhere
)
The paradox for England is that they may not be able to directly counter Bumrah—but they can shift the balance by attacking his supporting cast. India’s fast bowling depth looks less intimidating behind the main duo. Mohammed Siraj is dangerous but has struggled with consistency overseas. The remaining seam options—Shardul Thakur and Nitish Kumar Reddy—are more utility players than world-beaters.
Spin, too, presents a softer underbelly. Ravindra Jadeja, a superb operator on the subcontinent, averages over 44 with the ball in England. Kuldeep Yadav and Washington Sundar, both intriguing talents, have played just one Test between them in English conditions. If England’s aggressive batting unit can target the second- and third-tier bowlers—particularly when Bumrah is resting—it forces new Indian captain Shubman Gill into a dilemma: either bring Bumrah back earlier, risking burnout and diminishing returns, or let the game drift under less potent control.
This tactical pressure could be the real key to the series. England thrive on momentum. If they can exploit windows of vulnerability in the Indian attack, they may be able to mitigate the Bumrah factor by sheer weight of runs and tempo.
The Bashir wildcard
While England’s bowling blueprint appears clearer—with veterans like James Anderson and the ever-evolving Mark Wood leading the line—there’s a wildcard looming in the form of Shoaib Bashir. After making waves during England’s subcontinental tour earlier this year, Bashir could offer a fresh angle in conditions that traditionally favour seamers.
Though still raw, Bashir’s combination of height, flight, and drift gives him an edge many spinners lack in England. Should conditions flatten or begin to turn later in matches, his role could become more prominent—particularly with the inconsistency of India’s middle order on non-turning tracks. England’s gamble, as always under McCullum and Stokes, will lie in aggressive deployment. Expect Bashir, if selected, to be used not as a holding option but as a wicket-taker—regardless of match situation.
Final thoughts: pressure, opportunity, and the unknown
Both teams enter this series with tantalising possibilities. England are more settled in leadership and philosophy but still inconsistent in execution. India, meanwhile, have talent in abundance but must navigate the challenges of a new-look side and unfamiliar conditions. This is more than just a clash of star players. It’s a test of adaptability, of depth, and of who can better navigate moments of pressure across five potentially grueling matches. With Pope fighting for rhythm, Bumrah looming large, and both teams experimenting tactically, the narrative is wide open.
One thing is certain: this series won’t just be won with centuries or five-wicket hauls—it’ll be defined by the moments in between.
